The job ad is half written. “Digital Marketing Manager — small growing company, wear many hats, own our online presence.” You have two employees, neither of whom does marketing, and a nagging sense that you are losing work to competitors who rank higher on Google. Forty applications will arrive within a week and you will have no way to tell which are any good.
Stop before you post it. A business with one or two staff almost never needs a digital marketing manager. It needs one channel executed properly and one person accountable for it. A manager coordinates specialists and allocates budget. You have no specialists to coordinate and, at your size, a few hundred a month to allocate. Hiring a manager into that gap is the most expensive mistake available to you: you pay a salary for coordination work that does not exist, then pay again for the execution you actually wanted.
Why “digital marketing manager” is the trap
Look at what the label means to the labour market. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics files these roles under management, in the group “Advertising, Promotions, and Marketing Managers,” and describes the work as planning programmes and directing staff. Median annual wage for marketing managers in that category was $166,790 in May 2025, with the bottom ten percent still above $90,260. Advertising and promotions managers sat at a $133,660 median.
Those are direction-of-others salaries. Someone worth that number earns it by deploying six figures of media spend and managing three or four people. Give them no team and a $500 monthly budget and you have bought a very expensive pair of hands that has not used its own hands in years.
The category that actually contains your work is a different one: “Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists,” median $78,760 in May 2025, lowest ten percent under $43,390. The operative word is specialist. That is the person who builds the landing page, writes the email, sets up conversion tracking and runs the ad account. At your size, that is the job.
Worth knowing: there is no BLS category called digital marketing manager. The title is a market invention covering everything from a 23-year-old who schedules social posts to someone running a $2m media budget. Two candidates can hold it and share almost nothing, which is why it is doing your job ad no favours.
Your last twenty customers decide the role
Before you define anyone’s job, write down your last twenty customers, one line each, and next to each one how they first came to you. Not how you think they came. How they actually did. Referral. Found us on Google. Saw the van. Instagram. Someone’s cousin.
Most owners have never done this and are mildly surprised by the result. The usual pattern at this size: most of the twenty arrived through referral, repeat business or local search, and one or two through the channel the owner has been feeling guilty about neglecting.
That list is your job description. Three honest outcomes:
- Most came from search. You need on-page SEO, local profile work, service pages and conversion tracking. You do not need a social media person, however loudly one applies.
- Most came from referral and repeat. Your highest-return hire builds a review-collection habit, a customer email list and a follow-up sequence. Unglamorous, and almost nobody writes a job ad for it.
- You cannot tell. Then the first job is measurement, not campaigns. Two weeks of work: a source-of-enquiry question on every intake, call tracking, conversion tracking on the site’s forms and phone links. Google’s own guidance on setting up web conversions makes the point plainly, that understanding what users do after they click is what makes optimisation possible at all. Until that exists, every marketing decision is a guess with a budget attached.
Four realistic options, honestly costed
First make the BLS medians comparable, because employer cost is not salary. The BLS Employer Costs for Employee Compensation release for June 2026 put total private-industry compensation at $46.89 per hour worked: $32.82 in wages and $14.07 in benefits, so benefits ran 30 percent of the total. That is an all-industry average rather than a figure for one office role, but as a rough loading it means salary times about 1.43.
So a median marketing manager costs roughly $238,000 a year all in. A median marketing specialist, about $113,000. A junior at the bottom decile of that category, about $62,000. Per hour, roughly $115 of employer cost for the manager and $54 for the specialist. Now the four ways to get the work done.
A part-time specialist freelancer
One person, one or two channels, a fixed number of hours a month with a defined output. Against $115 an hour of loaded employer cost for the manager equivalent, a freelance specialist billing $60 to $100 an hour is not expensive; it is roughly at par with employing someone, and you pay only for hours worked. You get no coordination, no strategy layer, no holiday cover. Fits: one to five staff, one clear channel, an owner willing to be the decision-maker. This is the right answer for most businesses asking this question.
An agency retainer
You buy a slice of a team. At the small end the price does not tell you the effort; the hour count does. Ask how many hours a month the retainer represents and who does them, then divide. A vague answer means it is priced on what you will pay, not what will be delivered. Fits: businesses needing several disciplines touched lightly, or with a site and ad account needing maintenance nobody internally will ever learn.
A junior generalist you train
Cheap on paper, around the bottom decile of the specialist category, and the trap is that “train” means you. A junior needs their work checked, and if nobody in the business can tell good marketing from bad you have hired an unsupervised beginner and will find out in eight months. An intern is fine for defined, checkable tasks (reviews, listings, basic content) and a slow quiet leak the moment they touch an ad account unsupervised. Fits: only where the owner or a senior person knows the channel and has time to review, or where the junior is paired with a freelance specialist who reviews output monthly.
A fractional marketing lead directing freelancers
Someone senior for a day or two a month who sets direction, hires and manages the specialists, and reports to you. Priced at senior consulting day rates, so cost sits between freelancer and agency while capability sits above both. It only works if there is money for the freelancers underneath. A fractional lead with no execution budget is a consultant. Fits: a few thousand a month of total marketing money and more than one channel that matters.
The job description, before and after
The version nearly everyone writes:
“Digital Marketing Manager. Manage SEO, PPC, social media, email marketing, content strategy, website updates, analytics and brand development. Develop and execute our digital marketing strategy. 2+ years experience. Self-starter who can work independently.”
That ad selects for the one thing you do not want: a person confident enough to claim eight disciplines. It also tells a good specialist to keep scrolling, because they can see nobody in the building knows what the job is.
The same job, rewritten for a business whose twenty customers came mostly from local search:
“Marketing Specialist, 15 hours a week, local search and enquiry conversion. Two outcomes: (1) increase enquiries from Google search, measured as tracked calls and form submissions, from a baseline we will set together in week one; (2) get our enquiry-to-quote rate visible and improving, by fixing the pages people actually land on. Tools you will be in weekly: Google Business Profile, Google Search Console, GA4, our WordPress site, our call tracking. You will report to the owner and you will make the changes yourself, not write recommendations for someone else to implement. Budget for ads and tools is $X a month and you will propose how it is spent.”
Three things changed. The channel laundry list became two outcomes. Abstract “strategy” became named tools the person will have their hands in. And the budget is stated, which quietly filters out everyone who wanted a job where marketing means meetings.
Judging marketing skill when you cannot judge marketing
You do not need to become a marketer to run a good interview. You need to test for specificity, judgement and evidence of having done the thing. Three questions do almost all the work.
Ask them to critique what you have now. Send your website and, if you run them, a screenshot of your ads. Do not brief them. Then judge specificity and nothing else. A weak candidate says the site looks dated and the messaging could be stronger. A strong one says your phone number is an image so it cannot be tapped, the service page for your highest-margin job does not exist, the ads bid on a term that pulls in people wanting free advice, and the form asks nine questions when it needs three. Specificity is not a proxy for skill here. It is the skill.
Ask what they would stop doing. Every small business does a few marketing things out of habit that produce nothing. A candidate who only wants to add activity has never worked inside a real constraint. Someone good nominates something to kill and says why, and the reasoning references cost or attention rather than taste. It also tells you whether they will be honest when you are wrong, which matters more than channel expertise once they are in the job.
Ask for one campaign, end to end, with the money in it. Not their best work. One: what the goal was, what they did, what it cost, what it returned, what they would change. You are listening for whether they know the numbers. People who have run spend remember their cost per lead and their close rate the way a chef remembers oven temperatures. People who sat next to someone running spend describe the creative.
The portfolio problem
Marketing results are almost never attributable to one person, and every portfolio is built on that. “Grew organic traffic 240 percent” might mean they wrote every page, or that they were one of nine, someone else built the site, someone else bought the links, and the market grew anyway. Neither the claim nor the number is a lie. It just tells you nothing. So probe the contribution, not the result:
- “Who else worked on that, and what did they do?” Honest candidates answer easily and specifically. Evasion here is the most useful signal in the whole process.
- “What did you personally build or write, and can you show me it?” A page, an email, an ad, a spreadsheet. Something with their hands on it.
- “What else was happening in the business at the time?” New product, new funding, a competitor going under. Good marketers volunteer this, because they think in terms of attribution.
- “What did you try that failed, and how did you find out?” How they detect failure tells you whether they measure anything.
- Then pay for two to four hours of real work at their rate, on something you need. Cheapest interview stage you will ever run, and it beats every reference call.
The person is not the budget
This is where tiny businesses most reliably waste money. You approve a marketing hire, the whole amount goes to the person, and nothing is left to run anything with. Six weeks later a competent employee is producing weekly reports about a business that is doing no marketing.
Decide your total marketing money first, then split it. As a working rule at this size, put half to two-thirds into the person and the rest into media, tools and content. Ads need spend. Local search needs a site that works, sometimes a developer. Email needs a platform. Content needs time or a writer. If the split leaves nothing for any of that, you have hired a driver and no car.
The uncomfortable corollary: if your total marketing money is small, do not hire anyone. Spend it on the channel for a quarter and buy the person out of what it produces. A freelancer for eight hours a month plus real ad budget beats a part-time employee with no ad budget almost every time, because the constraint at your size is rarely labour. And below about five hours a month nothing compounds; the person spends the time reloading context. At that level buy a finished asset instead, like a tracking setup or a set of service pages.
The first ninety days, measured properly
Brand metrics are useless to you. Impressions, reach, follower growth and share of voice belong to companies big enough to bridge the gap between attention and revenue with a budget. Yours cannot. Measure things that lead to money, and set the baseline in week one, because a baseline reconstructed in month three is an argument waiting to happen. One page, read every fortnight:
- Tracked enquiries by source. Calls, forms, WhatsApp, walk-ins, source attached. If it does not exist on day one, building it is the first deliverable.
- Enquiry-to-quote and quote-to-job rates. Marketing that doubles enquiries while halving their quality has done nothing, and this is the only place you see it.
- Cost per booked job by channel. The number that settles budget arguments.
- Response time to a new enquiry. Often the highest-return fix of the whole quarter, and not a marketing problem at all, which is why a good hire raises it anyway.
- Things shipped. A literal list of what went live: pages published, ads launched, emails sent, tracking installed. In month one it is the only honest measure you have, because results have not had time to happen.
Day 30 judges whether real work shipped and whether measurement exists. Day 60, whether leading indicators moved: enquiry volume, cost per enquiry, search visibility for terms that matter. By day 90 you should be able to say what a customer from this channel costs. If you cannot, either nothing was tracked or nothing was done, and the shipped list tells you which.
So, this week: write the twenty-customer list. Split your total marketing money person-versus-media before you talk to anybody. Rewrite the ad as two outcomes and a tool list. Then hire the smallest capable thing, usually a specialist for a fixed number of hours with real budget to spend, reporting to you. Promote the arrangement later, once there is something to manage.
If you would rather not run that process alone, this is work AB7 Solutions does. On the hiring side we handle recruitment and contract staffing for exactly this shape of role, including part-time and remote marketing specialists, screened for the things above: hands-on tool experience, attributable contribution, willingness to ship rather than advise. On the execution side we run SEO, AEO and GEO programmes and build the websites, tracking and conversion plumbing a new marketing hire usually spends month one finding is missing. The pairing is the useful part, because it means we can tell you honestly which of the four options fits you, including the fairly common answer that you should not hire anyone yet. If a conversation would help, call +1 321 341 7733, email ab@ab7solutions.com or director@ab7solutions.com, or start at www.ab7solutions.com.
Sources: US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Advertising, Promotions, and Marketing Managers and Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists (median wages, May 2025); BLS Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, June 2026 (benefits at 30.0% of total private-industry compensation; an all-industry average, used here only as a rough loading); Google Ads Help, Set up your web conversions. Freelance, agency and fractional rates are not published by any statistical agency and are described here as structures rather than figures.
Related reading
Related AB7 service: digital marketing and SEO outsourcing.
[…] Hiring a Digital Marketing Manager for a Two-Person Business […]